Skip to content
Finance & Paycheck

Pre-Tax vs Roth 401(k): How Each One Changes Your Paycheck

Compare traditional (pre-tax) and Roth 401(k) contributions: the effect on each paycheck, taxes now vs later, and a worked $60,000 salary example.

Umar Umar Content Writer Published 3 min read
Pre-tax vs Roth 401(k) – Tuff Search guide
Share
In this guide
  1. The core difference
  2. Worked example: $60,000 salary, 6% contribution
  3. How to think about the choice
  4. Rules worth knowing
  5. Model your options
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Related calculators
  8. Related articles
  9. Sources

Many 401(k) plans let you choose between traditional (pre-tax) and Roth contributions. Both put the same amount into your account, but they treat tax differently, so your paycheck and your future withdrawals look different.

The core difference

Traditional (pre-tax) Roth
Taxed when you contribute? No: lowers taxable income now Yes: contributed from taxed pay
Taxed when you withdraw? Yes, as ordinary income Qualified withdrawals are tax-free
Effect on paycheck today Smaller reduction in take-home pay Bigger reduction in take-home pay
Social Security and Medicare Still apply Still apply
2026 employee limit $24,500 combined with Roth $24,500 combined with pre-tax

Worked example: $60,000 salary, 6% contribution

Single filer, 2026 standard deduction, state with no income tax, contribution of 6% = $3,600 a year.

Pre-tax 401(k) Roth 401(k)
Gross pay $60,000 $60,000
401(k) contribution −$3,600 −$3,600
Federal income tax −$4,588 −$5,020
Social Security + Medicare −$4,590 −$4,590
Take-home pay $47,222 $46,790
Per biweekly paycheck $1,816.23 $1,799.62
Bar chart comparing annual take-home pay: $47,222 with a 6% pre-tax 401(k) and $46,790 with a 6% Roth 401(k) on a $60,000 salary
Same $3,600 contribution: pre-tax leaves $432 more take-home pay this year.

The pre-tax option leaves $432 more in take-home pay this year: the $3,600 contribution avoids federal tax at this person’s 12% marginal rate (3,600 × 12% = $432). The Roth option costs more now but the money can come out tax-free later if the withdrawal rules are met.

Try it with your numbers401(k) CalculatorProject your 401(k) balance at retirement with employer match, compound growth and 2026 IRS limits ($24,500; $32,500 at…Open calculator

How to think about the choice

  • If you expect a higher tax rate in retirement than now, Roth contributions can be attractive.
  • If you expect a lower rate later, pre-tax contributions may save more overall.
  • Many people split contributions between both to spread the tax risk.
  • Employer matching contributions have traditionally been pre-tax, although some plans now allow Roth matches.

Rules worth knowing

  • Qualified Roth withdrawals generally require the account to have been open at least five years and you to be at least 59½ (or meet another qualifying condition).
  • From 2026, people whose prior-year FICA wages from the plan sponsor were over $150,000 must make any catch-up contributions as Roth.
  • Contributions of either type count toward the same $24,500 employee limit.

Whichever you choose, time is the biggest factor in how much your savings grow. See compound interest explained and the Rule of 72 for quick ways to estimate growth.

Model your options

Use the 401(k) calculator to compare growth, and a paycheck calculator to see the effect on each check. For limits, read 401(k) contribution limits for 2026.

Important

Important: This article explains how the calculations work using 2026 federal figures. It is not tax, legal or financial advice. Your actual withholding depends on your W-4, your employer’s payroll system and your state, so check your pay stub and official IRS guidance.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. Roth contributions do not lower your taxable income, so your take-home pay drops by the full contribution.

Yes, if your plan allows it. The combined total is limited to $24,500 in 2026 (plus catch-up if eligible).

No. Both types are still subject to Social Security and Medicare.

It depends on your tax rate now versus in retirement and your other savings. Many people use both. A financial professional can help with your situation.

Sources

Estimates, not adviceResults are estimates for information only, not tax, financial, medical or legal advice. Confirm important figures with a qualified professional. See our Disclaimer.

Share this guide

Related calculators

Umar

About the author

Umar

Content Writer · Tuff Search

Umar writes the guides on the Tuff Search blog. He explains how each calculation works in plain English, with worked examples, and checks every figure against official sources.

Keep reading

More finance & paycheck guides

View all guides